why do navy submarine’s have no windows?

I have noticed on all navy subs that there are no windows i know that they aren’t really necessary under the water but when they are surfaced or under the water but close to the surface wouldn’t that help with not having to rely on technology to see the enemy.

11 Answers

The absence of windows on modern military submarines is the result of the advance of technology rendering them uneccesary. Some submarines of an earlier period certainly had them. Royal Navy submarines of the ‘K’ class had enclosed wheel houses atop their conning towers to give the OOWs and lookouts better protection from the weather when surfaced. The wheel houses were outside of the pressure hulls and were equipped with windows. Like most submarines before the introduction of nuclear propelled ones, they spent most of their time on the surface.

I wasn’t going to answer, because a lot of the answers have parts that are absolutely correct, but then include things that are incorrect, as well.

So first: windows would seriously degrade the integrity of the hull of a submarine. The high strength steel that a submarine’s pressure hull is built with has many requirements and standards, and I promise that any type of window doesn’t improve that!

A window would also be useless in most depths that a submarine would be operating at.

When a submarine is near the surface, it will typically go to Periscope Depth. While not perfect, a rotating periscope can quickly look down any direction. A series of windows, even IF they could be made to see outside (which is impossible on the layout of a submarine still underwater at periscope depth), who wouldn’t be useful to know exactly each bearing they were looking down. The periscope can magnify what is being looked at, can transmit what it’s seeing to video, can show everyone precisely what bearing/direction is being looked down, can communicate directly with the fire control system for weapons employment, and so on. It’s integrated in a way that seems unlikely for. a window.

When the submarine is surfaced, there will be an Officer of the Deck and Lookout (at a minimum) up on the bridge. So they don’t need. Window, because they’re outside. They’ll communicate through an intercom and phone system to the watch standard below. Additionally, most of the boat is still underwater, so the reality is that a window would still be useless. And even while surfaced, somebody is usually looking out the periscope to help the OOD see further out and maintain more situational awareness to avoid hitting other ships out there.

For some other peoples’ comments:

-Withstanding a subsurface nuclear blast is not the design purpose of a submarine’s pressure hull, window or no window.

-While the Virginia Class submarine DOES have essentially digital video cameras, those are there in lieu of the traditional periscope’s old school series of mirror and optics, so it doesn’t really answer the «why no windows» question anymore than «because there’s a periscope» does.

-adaviel IS correct in that technically it would be possible to put a window in a submarine, however for the reasons that he and I mentioned, it wouldn’t be practical. Also (and this is conjecture) I’d imagine that in a situation involving torpedo evasion and wartime weapons situations, a window similar to the one on a research vessel would be much more of a weak point than what would be necessary for a war fighting sub to maintain its integrity.

Also, the officer of the deck isn’t the only one looking out the periscope. Only one person can look out at a time, obviously, but the Junior Officer of the Watch and Junior Officer of the Deck will both take rotations on the scope, along with the OOD.

-For Ror’s answer, his numbers 1, 4, and 5 make my brain hurt, along with his source as a self-described «Boat Captain».

Can submarines have windows?

21 Answers

Submarines do have windows, they just don’t open.

Yes — a Submarine’s windows are called portholes. They are very small because of the pressure of the water. Deep diving submarines might not have any for this reason.

Russian submarines have a few windows along the top front of the conning tower.

I’d rather be in a submarine with windows than one with screen doors.

Yes, but screen doors don’t work well on submarines!

why would a submarine need a window? lol. i would think the answer is no.

Its amazing how many people are answering that have no idea.

I’d say YES. 6 acutally. The periscopes and my four torpedo tubes!

1. It’s a little dark down there

2. What exactly do you want to look at?

3. Uh theres this thing called pressure that causes thins to implode at certain depths.

It could, but it would severely inhibit it’s performance diving very deep due to the pressure. It would weaken the structural integrity of the vessel. There are some sightseeing subs that have windows, but they do not diver very deep.

Yes, but it’s not a good idea. Visibility underwater usually isn’t that good out past a few hundred feet, and that’s on a good day, so no real need.

I think they DO have windows, therefore possessing the capability to HAVE windows.

Trending Questions

Trending Questions

Answer Questions

Answer Questions

Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

The Interesting Engineering Behind Submarines

Here is the interesting engineering behind submarines that keeps the crews alive, and well hidden in the most challenging of conditions.

As far as recent records indicate, humans have only been exploring deep below the surface in the last few hundred years. Although it is heavily disputed as to when the first submarine was made, many owe the title out to Cornelis Drebbel, a Dutch inventor acclaimed to have invented the world’s first navigable submarine in 1620.

Since, submarines have improved in mobility, strength, and stealth — some of which are capable of remaining submerged for up to three months underwater.

Here is the interesting engineering of some of the world’s most advanced submarines.

The Interesting Engineering of Submarines

Only a select few have descended into the deepest part of the world’s oceans called the Mariana Trench. In fact, more people have explored the moon compared to those who have conquered the absolute deepest spot on Earth deemed the Challenger Deep.

The first people to ever descend to the bottom of the Challenger Deep are hydronauts Don Walsh and Jacques Piccard. The team sunk their submersible, the Bathyscaphe Trieste, to the bottom of the ocean in 1960.

Source: US Navy/Wikimedia Commons

The Bathyscaphe Trieste

The bathyscaphe vessel dives below the surface and is supported by a surface float, instead of a crew. Previously, propelled deep-sea submersibles were supported by a float that remains at the surface of the water. Its cabin is narrow and small with just enough room for a two-person crew. The rest of the hull is taken up by scientific equipment used to investigate one of the world’s most hostile regions on the planet, the bottom of the ocean.

Since the two hydronauts explored the bottom of the trench in 1960, only a handful of humans have gone back.

The Challenger Deep speaks for one of the most difficult challenges engineers face — pressure and life support.

High pressures threaten to crumble the hull of any vessel. For every 10 meters of water descended the pressure goes up by an entire atmosphere. That is the same amount of pressure experienced on the surface of an object from the entire weight of the atmosphere from sea level, all the way up until the reaches of space. At the bottom of the Challenger Deep, the pressure exceeds 1000 atmospheres ( almost 15000 PSI ).

Only small spherical vessels can withstand the intense pressures at the bottom of the ocean. Manned submarines tend not to sink farther than one kilometer below the surface of the water. Modern submarines can operate independently and support a crew for weeks on end. The most advanced nuclear submarines can operate independently and supply the crew with life-support systems for months on end.

There are many types of submarines, some of which are electric, diesel, or nuclear powered. There is a large misconception that diesel engines directly power the propellers of a sub. Many people question how a diesel engine could possibly run underwater with enough oxygen for it and the crew, while somehow hiding the exhaust as well. Solving the problem is a much more trivial solution, not using the engine underwater at all.

How Crews and Engines Breath Underwater

The solution to keeping a diesel supplied with enough oxygen is simple. Diesel-powered submarines are typically hybrids. The diesel engine typically powers a generator which powers a battery pack. But the engine is only used while the submarine is surfaced. When the batteries run low, the submarine resurfaces and runs its engines to power its battery.

Carrying oxygen on board is the simple solution. Massive canisters are pumped full of air every time the submarine resurfaces. The system is fine for missions no longer than a month. However, governments are always pushing the bounds of naval capabilities. Most of the time, stealth is the number one consideration.

While submerged in water, the vehicle is hidden, on the surface of the water, however, a submarine becomes a sitting duck.

Of course, the problem remains — surfacing submarines and making them vulnerable.

BrainStuff explains the process of how engines breath in diesel submarines.

For electric and diesel-powered subs, the problem of oxygen still persists.

The solution does exist — electrolysis — the process of splitting water into hydrogen and oxygen using electricity. Unfortunately for fully electric and diesel subs, splitting water is too power intensive for their reserved power supply. Electric and diesel-powered subs simply do not carry enough energy on board to provide enough oxygen for the crew for extended periods of time. The process drains the batteries that drive the motor, forcing the vessel to the surface, defeating the purpose entirely.

Electrolysis

Electrolysis is typically reserved for the largest and most advanced subs — nuclear submarines. The process works by passing an electric current through water. The electricity provides the energy necessary to split the bonds of water or H₂O.

Electrolysis of water, Source: Nevit Dilmen/Wikimedia Commons

In a typical day, one person will consume about a kilogram of oxygen, along with a concoction of mostly inert gasses. Commercial electrolysis systems typically require approximately 50 kilowatt-hours of power to produce 1 kg of H2 and 8 kg of O2 from 9 kg of water. Instead of constantly draining batteries, nuclear submarines provide a constant source of power — enough to power a small city.

The system supplies more than enough oxygen, incidentally, hydrogen is made in the process. In normal operation, nuclear subs disperse the hydrogen directly into the water. However, during covert operations, secret methods are used to scrub the hydrogen from the exhaust.

Since some navies can detect the hydrogen releases in water, most scrubbing methods are kept secretive. Although, it is likely the subs use catalytic converters to add hydrogen to another compound. However, it is not the only stealth consideration submarine engineers must consider.

The Stealth Technologies of Submarines

Submarines make a ton of noise through their engines, propellers, and general operation. The noise causes vibrations which easily carry through the water for kilometers on end. Every part of a military submarine is built with the consideration of stealth. Every vibrating part is held in place with rubber mounts that actively dampen most of the vibrations. The technique works well on the outside, although it is not the only source of noise on the vessel.

Nearly all submarines are propeller driven. As the propellers cut through the water, they produce noise for a couple of reasons. One, the blades send out vibrations as they slice through the air, and two, the blades create cavitation bubbles which collapse, sending more vibrations throughout the water — as well as damaging the blade itself.

Cavitation bubbles form on the suction side of a propeller when the pressure of the water drops below the vapor pressure of water. As quick as the bubbles are produced, they almost just as quickly disappear. The bubble collapses on the propeller blade, causing them to wear down and release noise.

The noise is easily detected, therefore, it is imperative for submarine engineers to design sound suppressive blades that reduce cavitation.

Submarine engineers modify the shape of the propeller to reduce turbulence and reduce the overall noise of the blades as they slice through the water. Often times, there are four or more blades which force more water out of the way while spinning at slower speeds. The result is a propeller that does not need to spin as fast to produce the same speeds as propellers with fewer blades. Since the blades spin slower, there is less turbulence and less formation of cavitation bubbles. Sometimes, special groves are carved into the blades which further guide the water along with as little disturbance as possible, once again reducing the formation of cavitations.

The submarine is also streamlined to direct water through the blades, reducing as much turbulence as possible. If the design is not sufficient enough, a ring or cage is sometimes installed around the propeller which guides the water through more linearly.

Source: AndrejS.K/Wikimedia Commons

Other Sound Suppression Technologies

Suppressing the noise from the submarine itself is one challenge. But developing a sub capable of evading enemy sonar presents a different predicament.

Sonar is a device used to detect objects underwater. Sound pulses are emitted and a detector records any pulses that return. By determining the time it takes for a pulse to return, the distance between the detector and the object can easily be determined.

The massive hull of large submarines is hardly stealthy. As a metallic shell, the surface of a submarine readily reflects sounds, making it highly visible to enemy radar. The solution for hiding from radar comes from an unlikely source: bubbles.

Underwater, air bubbles easily absorb noise. As sound waves propagate through the water they slowly disperse over time. Introducing bubbles disturbs the sound, forcing it to travel through one medium to another, absorbing a little energy with each bubble.

Incoming sound vibrations collide with the bubbles, forcing the bubble to vibrate or contract and expand. The fluctuations cause the air inside to compress, creating heat. Essentially, the sound energy is converted from noise into heat.

Counter-intuitively, producing bubbles could actually disguise the sound signature of a sub. Although, it is nearly impossible to absorb all of the sounds, hence why anechoic tiles were introduced.

Sound Suppressing Tiles

Lining the outskirts of modern submarines are layers of anechoic tile, a rubber material with thousands of tiny voids. The material continues the effect of bubbles in water, without the need to dispense bubbles and reveal a position.

The material actively absorbs sonar while speakers may play predictable opposite tones to cancel some noise. Together, the two along with other technologies keep submarines hidden at all times, plotting on the floors of the ocean.

The extreme capabilities of modern engineers are the result of hundreds, if not thousands of years of trial and error. The interesting engineering of submarines keeps the crews alive, and well hidden in the most challenging of conditions. Space may be difficult, but it would seem the bottom of the ocean possesses the greatest challenge.